Wednesday, April 12, 2023

Chapter 1: Section 7: Pages 58-59: Lines 35-38 (1017-1020)

 "Mr. Rideout, we wander at the present moment through a sort of vorticalist twilight, holding up the lantern of the Maxwell Field Equations and squinting to find our way. Michelson's done this experiment before, in Berlin, but never so carefully. This new one could be the giant arc-lamp we need to light our way into the coming century. I don't know the man personally, but I'll write you a letter of introduction anyway, it can't hurt."

**********

"Mr. Rideout"
That'd be Merle! He's the guy with whom Heino is speaking! Try to keep up!

"wander at the present moment"
To wander: "walk or move in a leisurely, casual, or aimless way." Vanderjuice surely means to invoke the aimless choice in that definition due to science's current lack of knowledge about Æther (what is known at "the present moment").
    "The present moment" can be seen as a boundary or a dividing line between the past and the future. It contains all movement, all discovery. Pynchon sees this particular present moment (the end of the 19th Century and, probably the beginning of the 20th Century, judging by the size of the book!) as a critical juncture between many old academic ideas and what they will be replaced by. Or, perhaps, what new ideas will be killed by those who have gotten rich off the old ideas.

"a sort of vorticalist twilight"
The darkness of a deadly storm (vortex/tornado/hurricane) with a hint of danger due to the high winds and debris of cast aside or outdated theories. That's probably what he means! "Look out! Hollow Earth theory coming right at your head!"

"the lantern of the Maxwell Field Equations"
Published in 1861 and 1862, they proposed that light was an electromagnetic phenomenon, unifying theories on light, magnetism, electricity, and electromagnetic radiation, which had all been described previously as separate phenomena. Anyway, that's the simple gist of the Wikipedia entry and even that summation is threatening to crack open my brain. I suppose I should understand how light works much better than I currently do, seeing as how this book (at least this first section), is really focusing on the light theme.
    This phrasing is clever because the lantern is what is needed to make our way through the darkness and the lantern uses light and the Maxwell Field Equations provide answers to how light works to help us see our way to understanding light. And electricity. And, um, magnetism. Reading the rest of the Maxwell Equations Wiki entry has provided little help except to remind me how dumb I am.

"Michelson's done this experiment before, in Berlin, but never so carefully"
The problem with Michelson's previous experiment was that his device was subject to experimental errors too large to provide any meaningful results.

"This new one could be the giant arc-lamp we need to light our way into the coming century"
Fitting words as this experiment will, more or less, destroy science's fascination with Æther, allowing it to move forward in different directions, and eventually leading to Einstein's theory of relativity. Also fitting because he compares it to a giant arc-lamp needed to light the way. Again, he uses the metaphor of light to describe our ever-increasing knowledge of light itself. Also knowledge is always said to illuminate. I can't do all the math needed to understand how magnets create electricity which produce light (or whatever is going on there!), so instead I just look for dumb metaphors and apt analogies! I haven't taken a calculus class in 30 years but I've re-read like twelve Xanth novels in the last few years so that probably explains my intelligence level.

"it can't hurt"
When somebody says, "To tell the truth" or "To be honest," they've either just previously lied to you or are about to lie to you. In the same vain (vane? vein?), when somebody says, "It can't hurt," you better believe it fucking will.

Chapter 1: Section 7: Page 58: Line 34 (1016)

 "Think this is worth going out to Cleveland for?"

**********

Is anything worth going out to Cleveland for?

I'd suggest the use of Cleveland might be some clue to something Pynchon is saying, like how boundaries "cleave" the "land." But, historically, that's just where the experiment took place.

Chapter 1: Section 7: Page 58: Lines 32-33 (1014-1015)

 Indeed one finds in the devout Ætherist a propensity of character ever toward the continuous as against the discrete. Not to mention a vast patience with all those tiny whirlpools the theory has come to require."

**********

Damn. This whole "continuous versus discrete" thing is probably really important to the bigger picture! This sounds like he's talking about something more than just dissecting light and electromagnetic waves and an imaginary substance filling up our nostrils and buttholes. Since Vanderjuice's monologue (which ends with these two lines) is about the faith often needed to believe in Æther, I should just view this as an analogy of religion. Even though Ætherist looks like Atheist, the Ætherist would be the stand-in for a true believer. Their view is toward the infinite and the continuous, the undying soul that continues on in both directions from the finite body it only momentarily possesses. While the Atheist exists in our discrete and finite mortality, the only life we have to live. The Atheist's view is also the more scientific view, being that perception of evidence is only possible with our consciousness which only exists while we're alive.

"a vast patience with all those tiny whirlpools the theory has come to require"
While this can describe a scientific theory, it's a poor theory which scientists would probably only use because it was somehow working for some instance but knowing something better and which made more sense without needing a ton of exceptions would come along. So, really, the tiny whirlpools would be religious dogma needed to explain The Bible better, or to handwave away obvious contradictions.

Monday, April 10, 2023

Chapter 1: Section 7: Page 58: Line 31 (1013)

It certainly depends on a belief in the waviness of light—if light were particulate, it could just go blasting through empty space with no need for any Æther to carry it.

**********

Vanderjuice hits upon one of the greatest oddities in physics: the wave-particle duality. We now know light goes blasting through empty space. But it still acts like a wave in so many other regards. I don't know anything about physics (except how to strike a pool ball a certain way to get it to go where I want!) and even less about quantum physics. Maybe quantum physics explains this odd duality better, where something acts like a particle on Tuesday and then a wave on Thursday. But it seems to me there must be a third thing that is both somehow and we're all just too stupid to come up with a satisfying equation for it. It's probably because you can only understand the properties of the warticle when observing it from a higher dimension. Like in a balloon. Man, I sure miss the easy reading of the Chums of Chance chapters!

Chapter 1: Section 7: Page 58: Line 30 (1012)

 Sir Oliver Lodge defined it as 'one continuous substance filling all space, which can vibrate light . . . be sheared into positive and negative electricity,' and so on in a lengthy list, almost like the Apostle's Creed.

**********

"Sir Oliver Lodge"
Vanderjuice probably found this quote in Modern Views of Electricity from 1889 but I'm not going to read that book just to verify it. Sir Oliver Lodge also wrote a book in 1925 called Ether and Reality in which he defends his definition of Æther even though it was already a scientific relic of the last century. His need to believe in an invisible substance with a major effect on reality probably stemmed from his deep conviction in the afterlife, having been convinced by several mediums that he could speak with his son Raymond who had died in the First World War. His belief in spiritualism was seen as quite a flaw in the scientific community because Sir Oliver Lodge had pushed the knowledge of electricity and electromagnetic fields forward by some distance. He even received a patent used in radio which Marconi ultimately had to pay him to use. And spark plugs! His family sold spark plugs!

"one continuous substance filling all space"
For some reason, this brings to my mind this quote from Gravity's Rainbow: “If there is something comforting - religious, if you want - about paranoia, there is still also anti-paranoia, where nothing is connected to anything, a condition not many of us can bear for long.” It's as if Lodge's view of Æther is that of the paranoiac: the connection of everything to everything else via some invisible substance gives comfort. It is all connected. There's a strong meaning to be found in having things connected.

"which can vibrate light"
I suppose the vibrations of the Æther is what supposedly propagates the waves of light.

"be sheared into positive and negative electricity"
Is that how we get electricity? Shine light into a razor sharp angle so that it is split into positive and negative charges? It doesn't seem right but then it also kind of seems right in that static electricity is pretty much the shearing off of electrons onto something that isn't particularly capable of holding strongly onto those electrons and, as such, you shock the face of your cat and it gets pissed at you.

"Apostle's Creed"
First off, Mr. Pynchon, it is "Apostles' Creed." Normally I would put this blame on Vanderjuice, the speaker, but since there's no audible difference between the versions, I'm going to have to blame Pynchon, the colossal hack writer. Anyway, I only know that because being raised an areligious person, I had to look up what the hell the Apostles' Creed was. It's just a litany of "I believe" statements. I guess, in religion, that's how you argue logically. You just keep restating to yourself, again and again, that you believe in nonsense because if you ever stop declaring you believe it, you might actually think about it and see the pure nonsense yourself. So what Vanderjuice is saying is that Lodge's writing about Æther pretty much just amounts to a bunch of "I believe" statements without seeing any need to back them up with evidence. The colossal hack!

Saturday, April 8, 2023

Chapter 1: Section 7: Page 58: Line 29 (1011)

 Lord Salisbury said it was only a noun for the verb 'to undulate.'

**********

"Lord Salisbury"
Robert Arthur Talbot Gascoyne-Cecil, 3rd Marquess of Salisbury. He was Prime Minister of the United Kingdom three times in the latter half of the 19th Century. I don't know why he was weighing in on the possible existence of Æther except that people sometimes want to know what powerful politicians think. This guy seemed pretty smart if absolutely a model of conservative British politics. My favorite bit about him was his credo: "Whatever happens will be for the worse, and therefore it is in our interest that as little should happen as possible." Being the leader of the greatest imperial country of the 19th Century, this motto did not stop him from winding up with the most territory in the Scramble for Africa. I suppose that was more a case of the worst happening and less a case of as little should happen as possible. Because, you know, Britain could have sat out plundering Africa with the other imperialists, could they have not?



This guy looks like his credo.


"a noun for the verb 'to undulate.'"
I don't know if he really said this or this is just Pynchon fictionalizing some possible dialogues surrounding Æther at the time but it definitely sounds good! The main reason for Æther's existence was to give light waves something to travel, or undulate, through. The movement of light waves simply needed a medium, or noun, to make sense.

Chapter 1: Section 7: Page 58: Line 28 (1010)

 Some don't believe in it, some do, neither will convince the other, it's all faith at the moment.

**********

Think about science as theories based on observations and we can understand the kind of "faith" Heino means. If early "scientists" (just meaning curious people who actually consider the world around them rather than horny people just trying to get laid (which we need too! I'm not judging!)) were to first observe fish, and the only thing they knew was that they, and most animals they knew of, would drown underwater, they would probably come up with a story, or theory, as to how the fish survives. Religion is theory based on observation without evidence. That's where faith actually lies. Science is theory based on the current best understanding of what's being observed and which everybody knows is liable to change with new evidence. That's hardly faith! But back to the fish watchers! A theory one of the early scientists might come up with is that fish don't need to breathe. They're just different. Everybody might nod their heads and say, "Yeah, yeah! That sounds reasonable. They seem fine underwater yet no animals we know of can breathe underwater. Therefore fish don't breathe." Belief in that story would be Heino's version of faith. It makes sense through observation and an understanding of the world around them. But as soon as somebody takes a fish out of the water and sees the way it gasps and eventually dies, the theory would immediately change. Obviously the fish is trying to breathe! But it drowns on land the way people drown underwater! So they do breathe but they seemingly breathe water. Boom. That's the new story that some will believe, some won't, and nobody will convince the other because the evidence to support either assertion isn't in yet. It's all faith.