He understood that things were exactly what they were. It seemed more than he could bear.
* * * * * * * * * *
Occasionally I'll break my "One Line at a Time" rule because the lines need to remain together. A semicolon would have been nice here, Pynchon! Maybe think of bloggers who will eventually get sued into taking down their blog because it's reprinting your whole book one line at a time when you write your next novel, okay?!
Lew's moment of clarity, written simply, and heartbreakingly familiar.
There's a feeling I've been having lately, at 49, that I truly never expected to feel: humans live too long. My entire life was always plagued by the idea that our lifespans are so short. And yet, lately, it seems like all the color has worn off my surroundings. It's like being in a library where every book has been read. And it's realizing that a large percentage of the other humans on this planet are selfish, violent bullies stripped of empathy and compassion.
I re-watched The Hobbit: Battle of the Five Armies last night and was gutted by the elves going to war. Before one of them even died, I was heartbroken by the fact one of them might. How does one justify the sacrifice of immortality for a brief and bloody conflict? I absolutely didn't judge Thranduil when he was ready to walk away from the war. A man is sacrificing maybe twenty or thirty years; an elf is gambling eternity. Sure, a life is a life. But Thranduil is fucking right when he asks what the difference is if a dwarf dies today or in ten years or in a hundred. I was on his side so hard even though he was meant to be seen as a selfish isolationist not willing to do what was needed to save the world.
I had a dream once where an old woman was asking me about my cat, Judas. Eventually she asked if I'd kill my pet to save the world. And I easily and quickly answered, "No." I told that dream to my cousin and, years later, she asked me if I remembered that dream I had. And I said, "Yes, of course." She said, "You were right." She hadn't thought so at the time. But she eventually came to realize the truth of it. There is only so much we can give for this world; some times we are asked too much. Not only would I not have killed Judas to save the world; I would have given my life to save my best friend.
I miss him so Goddamned much.
Maybe it's not that we live too long. Maybe 49 isn't the problem. Maybe it's that my grief over a damn cat simply overwhelmed me and stole the colors from my world. Maybe Tauriel's grief of Kili, and the loss of love, and the need to have love taken from her, affected me more than I want to admit. Maybe immortality is too much to bear when heartbreak and loss exist. Of course, that's part of the reason Thranduil decides to abandon the battle. He's not an unfeeling king. Tauriel has lost one dwarf she recently fell in love with and it's too much to bear; how much then is Thranduil suffering upon looking at his friends lying mutilated all across the battlefield?
Heartbreak is too much to bear and yet, at the same time, it's entirely worth it. Because it's inevitable when one allows themselves to love so much.
"It seemed more than he could bear." Such a simple sentence full of power. What a great description of life and everything in it.
Sorry for rambling.
Lew, having his moment of clarity, seeming almost like a mystical revelation, actually winds up doing the opposite: he sees through the veil of hope and magic and possibility to stare the mundane world directly in the face. This is it, Lew. This is life. Troth is gone. Live with it. And he thinks, "I don't know if I can."